Dear {eminent law professors X and Y},
You might find interesting this close reading of an aspect of the formal rational basis in U.S. v. Morrison (529 U.S. 598):
http://acrosswalls.org/formal-rational-basis-false-domestic-violence/
At the intake end of the criminal justice system, arrests for domestic violence now account for about 60% of arrests for interpersonal violence. Change in capacity to reason about domestic violence is associated with the development of mass incarceration:
http://acrosswalls.org/domestic-violence-policies-mass-incarceration/
Please take these issues seriously.
Regards,
Communicating with Prisoners Collective
acrosswalls.org
{response from eminent law professor Y}
I don’t usually respond to emails like this. But let me say: domestic violence against women has gone on far too long unpunished. If incarceration is the current response, I am not ashamed. I have serious difficulties with incarceration as the only penalty. That does NOT excuse violence perpetrated in women by men.
{our response}
Thanks for your response. You seem not to understand. See:
http://acrosswalls.org/section/gender-imprisonment/domestic-violence/criminal-suspicion/
http://acrosswalls.org/men-ignored-domestic-violence-injuries/
http://acrosswalls.org/notes/history-criminalization-domestic-violence/
You should be ashamed.
{response from eminent law professor Y}
Nope.